Do Face Masks Really Protect Against Covid-19 As Claimed?

Public health officials have launched a protracted campaign to make us believe that wearing a face mask prevents the spread of Covid-19, the latest pandemic. But is this true? That was the question on the mind of a Duke physician, Eric Westman, who was a champion for people putting on masks. He wanted to be sure that he was recommending the right prevention technique to people and businesses. So he decided to carry out a proof-of-concept study. A proof-of-concept study is a study that aims to test whether a technique or method is really as effective as claimed. Also it is used in science as a testing phase to verify the feasibility of a method, a technique or even an idea. When scientist carry out an investigation in science, they start with an idea like this.

 

Doctor Westman was working with a non-profit and he needed to provide face masks to people. He was also skeptical about the claims that mask providers were making about how effective their marks were against a pandemic like covid-19, so he went to a chemist and physicist at the University, Martin Fischer, Ph.D. and asked him to carry out a test on various face masks. The test they did was based on both surgical masks used in medical settings and cloth face masks. They also carried out tests on bandanas and neck fleeces used by people who claim they can prevent the spread of covid-19.

Fischer’s line of work usually involves exploring the mechanisms involved in optical contrast while doing molecular imaging studies. He was intrigued by the doctor’s challenge so he set out to help him. For the study he used materials that were freely available; something that can easily be bought online. These materials include a box, a laser, a lens, and a cell phone camera.

From the study it was reported that it proved positive and showed that face mask were effective at preventing the spread of Covid-19. They recently published their scientific study article in the journal “Science Advances”. Despite this being a low cost technique, it helped to prove that face mask prevent droplets coming out of the mouth while speaking, sneezing or coughing from being transmitted from one person to another. They reported that while carrying out the study they could see that when people speak to each other, cough, or sneeze that molecules of droplets are passed from one person to the other. They also confirmed that it is not all masks that are effective at preventing the spread of droplets. Some face coverings were seen to perform better than others in preventing the spread of droplets.

So how did the masks compare? They tried out the proof-of-concept study on various masks and compared their effectiveness. They found that the best masks were the N95 masks which were used in medical settings. They also found that surgical masks and masks made of polypropylene were equally effective in preventing the spread of droplet molecules. Face masks which were made from cotton allowed some molecules to pass through but were found to have good coverage. They could eliminate several droplets that were being passed when people were speaking. Overall it was shown that bandanas and neck fleeces should not be used at all or recommended as face covering. This was because they were ineffective in blocking the spread of droplet molecules.

When the physicist was asked if this was the final word on the subject, he replied in the negative. Therefore more studies need to be carried out because this is just a demonstration to show the effectiveness of various face masks. The study was done to help businesses see that they can carry out these tests themselves before investing on any type of face mask or face covering.

When asked on the benefits of the study, Westman, who was inspired to start it, said that many people and businesses have been asking him about how they could test all these face masks that were new in the market. So he decided to show that businesses could carry out the tests themselves with very simple materials. He said that the parts for the testing were easily purchased online and they were putting out this information to help others.

As they hoped, they have shown that various face coverings that were being promoted by public health officials were indeed effective in preventing the transmission of molecular droplets from one person to the other.

Although this is just a proof-of-concept and not a rigorous testing technique, one can confidently recommend the use of face masks to individuals and businesses because they really work in preventing the spread of covid-19. My advice to everyone is to stay safe, wear a face mask, and help stop the spread of covid-19. We will see an end to this soonest. Please, carry out social distancing and regular hand washing to prevent the spread of this current pandemic.

Material for this post was provided by the dukehealth.org website.