Is There Life On Venus? Or Are We Alone?

Recently, it was reported in the media that phosphine has been discovered in the acidic clouds of planet Venus. According to scientists, phosphine is a biosignature for life; that means it can only be produced by living organisms. This discovery raises several questions in the minds of many, some of which are: “Are we alone? How substantial is this evidence?” Only time will answer this question when the research is well investigated. According to Carl Sagan, a famous astronomer and astrobiologist: “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.” And that certainly applies to this situation.

 

What type of planet is Venus?

Planet Venus is the second planet from the sun in our solar system. As you would expect, the temperatures there are very high. Temperatures can range up to 900 degrees Fahrenheit on the surface; so hot that it could melt lead. There are heavy clouds that swirl around the planet that are so acidic that we could not even measure them using our pH scale on earth. That is why Venus is referred to as a hell scape. It would be difficult to imagine life as we know it being on Venus.

Despite that fact, astronomers have voiced that possibility in the past. It was formerly proposed by Carl Sagan, an astronomer, and Harold Morowitz, a biologist, that there was a possibility that microbes could be existing in its acidic clouds; swirling around the planet. So, to confirm this idea, probes were sent to Venus to check out the planet and true to type, those probes melted on entering the planet. So, scientists have concentrated their search for life on the planet to browsing its clouds for microbial life.

What do we know about the gas, phosphine?

Phosphine gas that was discovered on the clouds of Venus is a toxic and explosive molecule with a lingering odor of garlic and dead fish. The gas was discovered on planet Venus at temperatures that were close to that on planet Earth. But the discovery was not much. The researchers describe it as: “finding some tablespoonfuls in an Olympic size swimming pool.” Yet, that amount is enough to pique our curiosity. This is because of how the gas is made here on Earth.

Phosphine gas on earth is made from either of two paths: as a natural byproduct of life, or it is manufactured artificially to produce fumigants and other biochemicals. As a byproduct of life, it is made by oxygen-hating microbes who live in swamps and marshes. It has been noticed by scientists that all living beings contain these microbes and they have called this gas the “biosignature of life”. So, with the reputation phosphine has earned, finding it on planet Venus raises a possibility: “could there be alien life on planet Venus, even if it is restricted to gas-eating microbes?”

Wise to be cautious

The data that has been collected on the presence of phosphine gas in Venus is not substantial to make astrobiologists certain that there could be alien life on planet Venus, although one could say that the potential is there – just potential. The gas could be coming from something else rather than life. An international team of researchers have set out to simulate possibilities for the existence of the gas, modeling scenarios like lightning strikes and meteors bombarding the clouds to see if such could produce any amount of phosphine on the surface of the planet but they came up short. Therefore, one can say that this detection is extraordinary. If nothing else can explain it, then alien life could be the answer. But considering the nature of Venus – a harsh place for life to inhabit – it would take a really strongly acid-loving microbe to be living in those clouds.

That is why scientists are not saying there is alien life yet. The astronomy community has gone this path before of proclaiming that there is alien life only to be disappointed. So, they would rather be cautious and optimistic rather than put a foot out. Also there are still details about the research that needs to be explored.

First, other researchers need to give credence to the claim that the gas is really phosphine. Venus clouds are surrounded by sulfur dioxide and this could influence the readings. Also, observations of the Venetian atmosphere would have to be done to confirm the existence of phosphine gas.

If it is really confirmed that the gas detected is phosphine, then the next step for researchers is to determine the source of the gas. This is really important for an hypothesis to be drawn. It would be foolhardy to run to conclusions at an early stage and say the source is biology. Other possibilities have to be explored and confirmed. If in reality scientists agree that the source is biology, then Venus would have to be explored and discovered. Missions would be sent to Venus to discover where on the clouds the microbes could be existing and if they could lead us to other areas on Venus. The microbe-hunting missions have to be well planned to prevent contaminating the Venetian clouds.

As it is, the data gathered so far cannot answer these questions. Therefore, we will have to wait and see what future research would turn up. If we could find habitable life on other planets, it would help man understand his place in the universe. It would help us understand what it means to be alive; what conditions prompt life and how we can extend it. There is a possibility that Venus would be a planet of future interest to astronomers and astrobiologists as they explore the recent findings about phosphine on the planet.

But right now, we don’t have any definite answer to the question: “Are we alone on the solar system?” We might never have an answer. But exploring the possibilities will open up new vistas of knowledge and expand our ability to solve some of the pressing challenges of planet earth.

The video below is an interesting news commentary on this discovery. Enjoy it.